A conversation with the charter fisherman
Interview by Bruce A. Percelay
Photography by Kit Noble
After a career on the water and countless hours in town board meetings, charter fishing captain Bobby DeCosta decided he needed to take things into his own hands. A decade removed from his last term on the Nantucket Select Board, DeCosta launched a write-in campaign for a third term on the board earlier this year. Even though his name did not appear on the ballot, he managed to garner 1,919 votes, the most votes any candidate to a town board had received in nearly 20 years. DeCosta sat down with N Magazine this fall to discuss the biggest issues facing the town, from the cost of housing to the rise in lone star ticks, and what the town needs to do to address them.
You have fished out of Nantucket nearly your entire life. In the last decade, have you noticed any remarkable changes in the species or the quantity of fish you’re finding that have either hurt or helped your business?
DeCOSTA: I’ve watched the striped bass population my whole life go from tons of fish in the ’60s and ’70s to a five-year moratorium in the ’80s to where the fish came back in the ’90s and the 2000s. Now we’ve had five years of very low [striped bass] that can be attributed more to the health of Chesapeake Bay than anything else. This year, we had the best [striped bass] hatch in the spring since 2018. I would not be surprised if we see some type of partial closure or complete moratorium in the next five years to give the stock a chance to rebound.
The bluefish numbers are way down compared to what it was when I was a kid and from when I first took over the charter business in 1993. My dad started fishing here in the ’40s, and he remembers in the ’50s there was a five-year period when they didn’t catch a bluefish on Nantucket, so they seem to be cyclical as well.
How has fishing on Nantucket, both recreationally and as a profession, changed since your childhood?
DeCOSTA:
My dad started the charter business in ’68 and prior to that, he was a fireman, but he also commercially fished. A lot of guys commercially fished to supplement their income, whether it was scalloping in the winter or fin fishing for bass and blue fishing in the summer months, in spring and fall. We had three fish markets on the island that actively bought fish and shipped fish off Nantucket. We don’t really have that here at all now, except for scallops. We also had a working ice house and we had working commercial docks. We don’t have any of that anymore.
Back then, guys couldn’t afford boats, so they fished from the beach pretty consistently. You could access every inch of beach on this island. You could drive on the beach at Jetties Beach and drive all the way around the tip of Coatue, and there were no closed beaches. There were no endangered bird [closures], so guys just drove to where the fish were, and they fished hard off the beaches. That all has changed.
A viable alternative to expanded hunting is to hire professional sharpshooters through the USDA or a private firm. What are your thoughts on sharpshooters significantly reducing the herd, and are there alternative approaches?
DeCOSTA: I’m not in favor of it. Basically, we’re talking about night culling. They call themselves sharpshooters, but they’re no different than half the hunters on this island with a small caliber suppressed rifle. [They] drive around the neighborhoods and shoot [the deer] at 3 a.m. on somebody’s lawn. First of all, you’ve got to pay somebody to do it, but you’ve got guys here that will do it for nothing, and would be happy to do it. If it comes to that, I would rather see us find 10 or 20 local guys and make sure they’re trained properly to do it. We did an aerial survey when I was on the Select Board the first time [in 2013]. They estimated the number of deer that they counted in February when we had a snow cover on the ground. They flew the island with thermal cameras and they did it from the plane back then because they didn't have drones.
They estimated that the herd was around 2,000 deer based on the numbers that they counted. Most of the deer that they found at that point were in backyards. Around the cranberry bogs or behind the dump, there weren’t that many deer. But when you flew Cliff Road, Polpis Road or Tom Nevers across from the Cranberry Bog, that’s where all the deer were. You can get those deer out of those neighborhoods with a bow and arrow in January and February, especially when most of the homeowners in these houses aren’t there. All they have to do is write permission to a hunter, and he can sit right on the porch and shoot him off the porch with a bow. You don’t necessarily have to send a sharpshooter in there at 3 a.m.
The state now estimates as many as 8,000 deer live on Nantucket. How can you reduce the herd to even 2,500 if the reproduction rate is roughly equal to the number of deer that hunters take each year?
DeCOSTA: This year we added two weeks of hunting in the fall, and we’re adding nearly two months in the winter. The number of deer that will be killed this year in January and February, I think you’re going to see a couple hundred extra deer killed at least. If you’re killing 100 does, each one of those does is probably pregnant, so you’re killing anywhere from 200 to 400 deer, depending on whether they’re having singles, twins or triples. That’s a big difference. You’ve got a lot of areas on this island where you can’t kill deer right now. You can’t hunt deer on any of the Linda Loring property or the Audubon properties, which are loaded with deer. You can’t kill deer in Ram Pasture, except for the Head of the Plains, and that’s only for five days. These are all areas that people walk and get ticks on, and these are all areas that have large amounts of deer. If you opened them to hunters even for four or five days, and just said, “All right, we’re going to close down this property to dog walkers for five days and let the hunters go in here and kill deer,” you would be amazed at how many you took out of these areas.
Moving on to town government, do you think the town needs to reimagine how it operates on a broader scale, possibly to a mayoral system?
DeCOSTA: I could see that, but I don’t think it will happen in my lifetime. Any changes like this have to go to Town Meeting, and I don’t see Town Meeting ever giving up their authority. The government study committee had looked at this pretty hard, and they thought that a town council form of government to get away from Town Meeting would work. I think it will go down very hard and fall in flames at Town Meeting. People like to come to Town Meeting and say their piece.
You have been critical of excessive town spending on large capital projects, the sluggish pace of government bureaucracy and the reliance on consultants. Does the town need to rein in municipal spending?
DeCOSTA: We’re not a little town anymore. We’re a small city. We can call ourselves a town still, but we have 15,000 people living here, we have a pretty big budget, and we have a lot of things that I don’t think we need. I think we need to streamline our government some. We’re going in so many different directions with so many different departments. I’m worried about the rate we’re spending money. This year we’re looking at probably coming in with another $100 million in overrides, and our budget for the next 10 years is almost $1 billion, even after all the cuts we made. I know everyone says, “We don’t have to pay for it, we have our summer residents to foot the bill.” But at some point, everyone’s going to just say, “Enough is enough.”
I’m not against spending money when you need to spend money, but sometimes, I think we overstudy things and we get too far off the mark. I would like to see us be a little more focused. Let’s take care of our important services, like making sure the roads are right, making sure we have a good fire department, a good police department, and municipal employees are happy. We need to house our municipal employees to make sure that we have good qualified people and schools. It’s no secret that I’m not a big believer in this whole coastal resiliency plan and the $550 million they want to spend on that stuff. I just think we have more important things to spend money on than that.
Housing for the middle class has become an issue whereby islanders can no longer afford to live here. If you go out 10-20 years from now, and the trajectory continues the way it is, what happens to Nantucket?
DeCOSTA: There’s no easy answer. My son and his fiancée are a perfect example. He’s a fireman and she’s a nurse at the hospital. They make good money together between the two of them, and they probably won’t afford to buy a house here. My wife and I have discussed building an [accessory dwelling unit] and moving into the ADU as we get older and giving them the house. The ADUs could help the problem, but if we’re going to build all these ADUs, I think we need to have some type of restriction that they have to be for year-round occupancy. The reality is that we’re going to retain a lot of employees for three to five years, whether they’re teachers, nurses, doctors, firemen or policemen. They’re going to come here, get a job, work for the town, gain experience, and then they’re probably going to leave because they can live a better lifestyle somewhere else. It’s not any different than any other resort community, whether it’s Aspen or Vail. They have the same issues.
People have said for decades that Nantucket is at a tipping point with too much traffic, too many visitors and too much development. At what point does Nantucket have difficulty functioning or lose its appeal because it’s reached a tipping point?
DeCOSTA: I don’t think that we’ll get to the point where our visitors feel that way. For every one person that I’ve ever met that gets on the boat and says this place is cooked and they’re never coming back, five more get off and say this is the best place they’ve ever been. Some of our seasonal residents complain about the traffic, but they’re the ones that have been here for a while. I see it more from our year-round population. I think that the 30-year-olds are looking at it and saying, “I’m making good money, but I can’t afford to live here.” If the quality of the schools go down and the quality of services go down, they’re going to leave. There are other places they can live and work and have the same quality of life or a better quality of life. We don’t seem to have the multigenerational families that are staying here as they used to. At least that’s what it looks like to me. If you’re a kid in your 20s or 30s and you don’t have a parent to help you or leave you a piece of property or something like that, you’re pretty well cooked here.