The impact of Nantucket's housing crisis
Written by Larry Lindner
Photo by Brian Sager and Kit Noble
"I’m a 42-year-old professional, and I have two housemates,” said Peter Burke, the executive director of the Nantucket Chamber of Commerce. Burke isn’t complaining. “I don’t have a family. I don’t have dogs. I actually feel pretty lucky that I have stable year-round housing,” he said. A carpenter on the island does not feel so lucky. Even though he earns about $120,000 a year, he struggles to pay rent. He and his wife finally moved from a cramped studio to a one-bedroom apartment in August, but it’s just a temporary fix because the landlord would only give him a one-year lease.
“I’m paying almost $4,000 a month,” he said, speaking on the condition of anonymity. Next year the landlord “may charge $300 more. Year by year they go higher and higher.” With the man’s business expenses, including insurance, equipment and vehicle maintenance, he simply does not know how he’s going to make ends meet—or where he and his wife are going to live—when the lease ends next summer.
The problem of affordable housing for people who earn a living on Nantucket is only worsening. “The market just really isn’t creating enough year-round housing,” said the island’s housing director, Kristie Ferrantella. “We’re even seeing a decrease in the opportunities” to make it available. The housing issue affects every stratum of Nantucket’s middle class. “I have six vacant police officer positions,” Police Chief Jody Kasper said. “We just conducted interviews with candidates, and we lost three of them due to housing.” Fire Chief Michael Cranson made the same point. “The fire department currently has five vacancies,” he said. “In recent hiring cycles, some otherwise strong candidates couldn’t move forward because they couldn’t find housing on the island.” Meanwhile, “some staff who cannot find housing on-island commute from off-island, which can affect ‘recall to duty’ situations and the fire department’s efficiency.”
Put in practical terms, if you can afford a home on Nantucket and your house catches on fire, there’s a risk that the response might not be what you’d expect because those tasked with protecting the community's infrastructure are often priced out of that very community. With one-bedroom rentals in the ballpark of $4,000 a month, a police officer who earns between $100,000 and $120,000 a year spends close to 50% of a year’s pre-tax annual salary for that small unit. If the officer has a family and needs two or three bedrooms, the rent is going to be considerably higher.
There isn’t a single aspect of life on Nantucket that isn’t touched by the affordable housing crisis. “I need an assistant manager pretty desperately,” said Acting Airport Manager Preston Harimon. “We built a dormitory-style facility over on Nobadeer Farm Road. [While it] can be used as a crutch for new year-round employees, it’s mainly intended for seasonal workers, May through October. The dorms have helped, but they’re not the whole answer.”
The difficulties have spread to Nantucket’s public school teachers as well. Superintendent Elizabeth Hallett commented that Nantucket leads the state in the starting teacher salary, currently $80,153. That gets teachers hired, she said, “but the more challenging piece is how to keep people here. We often lose people between the three- and seven-year mark. Just when they’re really coming into their own as highly qualified professionals, they leave and go to another district because they want to buy a house."
That’s nearly impossible to do on Nantucket on a teacher’s salary because of the island’s median sales price of more than $4 million. The inability to put down roots presents a real challenge, Hallett said. “We are constantly training new teachers, providing them with really good professional learning. We have to constantly consider the turnover.”
Retail businesses suffer, too. According to a report based on surveys and interviews completed by 72 island employers and released by Remain Nantucket, nearly 70% of employers provide some kind of housing support to their workers, costing them, at a minimum, $92 million a year. The median housing cost, per business, comes to $162,500. Even with housing subsidies for workers, 64% of business owners have lost or declined hires because of issues related to housing, according to Remain. The kicker: 72% of the employers surveyed expect their housing needs to grow, turning those employers into sometimes reluctant landlords whose resources get shunted away from growing their businesses.