Raising the Bar


November 19, 2026

Written by Brian Bushard

Photography by Kit Noble



Introducing The Dive


Zebra print and crocodile skin. Quite possibly the last things you would expect to find at a restaurant in downtown Nantucket. And yet at The Dive, a new restaurant and bar on South Water Street, a safari of animal print is staring you straight in the face as you walk in the front door. “This high-energy, youthful, exuberant vibe is something that Nantucket is missing,” said Denise Corson, a co-owner of The Dive. “There are not a lot of places that have zebra print and flamingos. That’s definitely missing.”


With a flock of inflatable flamingos strewn in the rafters and on the bar, The Dive is to interior design what yacht rock is to music. That is to say, it’s something good in its own right that isn’t taking itself too seriously. In a high-end restaurant scene of $40 small plates, The Dive counters with mozzarella sticks, fried calamari and roasted cauliflower. And to drink, a Bud Light, a P*rn Star Martini, or maybe a Pink Flamingo, a cocktail of Bacardi, grenadine and pineapple juice served in a glass on an inflatable pink flamingo.


 “Our goal is to bring a shareable approach to things,” Corson said. “Can I say that’s missing on Nantucket? I’m not sure. Our goal is to be able to bring a very upscale environment with a casual attitude where people can meet and have fun.”    The Dive had a soft opening over the summer, bringing customers back into the South Water Street space that had previously gone by the names The Charlie Noble, Cy’s Green Coffee Pot and the Atlantic Cafe. For the past year, it had been dormant, undergoing myriad renovations by its new ownership group, called Sneaky Good Hospitality. It’s the team behind a half dozen Boston restaurants, including Rock & Rye, Pinky’s and The Flamingo.


Anyone who hasn’t been inside since its days as The Charlie Noble will be in for a surprise. In addition to the zebra print and faux crocodile skin, the new restaurant features a U-shaped bar in the front and a second bar facing out toward Easy Street and Nantucket Harbor. “The U-shaped bar lends to the communal sense of a good time,” Corson said. “We can all look together and socialize. You’re looking at each other in the eye rather than the back of each other’s head.”


As far as the menu goes, the focus is on small, shareable plates, and “nothing that’s going to be scary,” Corson said. “The food and drink menus are going to be comfortable, fun, shareable, cheersable cocktails and food. It’s going to change and evolve from what it is now. The more we grow into ourselves, the more the menu and cocktail list is going to grow.”


Inside The Green Room

Besides the house-made nut mix, breadsticks and olives, you won’t find much food on the menu at The Green Room, the newest bar in town. It might be only the second true bar on Nantucket, second only to The Chicken Box.


“We want to be a complementary addition to the restaurant scene,” said Evan Leventhal, who opened The Green Room on North Water Street in August. Leventhal also co-owns the Greydon House with Elliot Gould and his brothers Alexander and Jeremy Leventhal. “You can imagine a lot of these bars are packed with people waiting for dinner. People can’t just sit and grab a drink at a lot of restaurants because they’re so food-oriented. We wanted a pre-drink and after-drink spot, and even an early afternoon spot where people can grab a drink and a small bite here, but have a more full meal somewhere else.”


Like its neighbor Via Mare, The Green Room is a vibe unto itself. True to its name, the walls are painted green. Beyond the bar, an assortment of low-top tables and coffee tables, wicker chairs and leather chairs, sofas and nooks, giving it the feel of an open-space living room, adorned with bookcases, chests, porcelain, a lightship basket, conch shells, transom windows, globes, sconces and plenty of paintings of old ships. “I’ve noticed a lot of people coming in as the afternoon shoppers that want to pop in and sit down for a little bit,” Bar manager Shannyn Trujillo said. “There’s a huge pre-dinner and post-dinner crowd, so everyone’s coming in at least for one or two cocktails, going to wherever their reservation is.”


Cocktails and wine are the name of the game at The Green Room. Fan favorites so far have been the neon green tequila and curacao cocktail bursting with fresh mint called The Myth, a bright pink option with house-infused hibiscus tea vodka, yuzu and limoncello called The Petal, and a bourbon and maple forward low ball called The Night Watch. And as a sign of the times, there’s also an entire page on the menu dedicated to non-alcoholic mocktails.


The Green Room is set to stay open year-round, with several months off during its first winter. In addition to free bar snacks and an abbreviated snacking menu, Trujillo said the menu will include caviar, tinned fish and potentially a charcuterie or cheese plate down the line. “It’s going to be drinks, little light bites, and we always want to have something complimentary to everyone as well, which doesn’t really happen out here. But if you go to a lot of places in New York or in Europe, they’re giving you a little something,” Trujillo said. “It’s a place where you can come and feel relaxed but well taken care of.”

Latest Stories


By N Magazine • November 19, 2026
Lisa & Tom's Nantucket wedding.
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Fashion
Nantucket Cottage Hospital’s longest employee retires
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Nantucket Cottage Hospital’s longest employee retires
Kezia Duarte on track to finish the six major marathons
By John Stanton • November 19, 2026
Kezia Duarte on track to finish the six major marathons
Barnaby's Cares provides hope.
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Barnaby's Cares provides hope.
Dan Pronk's lobster pot tree
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Dan Pronk's lobster pot tree
MORE STORIES