A Slice of Heaven


November 19, 2026

Internationally ranked Neapolitan pizza by Gemelle's Elio DiMambro

Written by Jack Bradner

Photography by Brian Sager

Recipe By Elio DiMambro

For Elio DiMambro, the chef at Pizzeria Gemelle, pizza napoletana is an art. Spending summers in Italy with his extended family, DiMambro grew up in and around the pizzeria on the ground floor of his grandparents’ apartment building. “As soon as I could reach the stove, in the back of my mind, I always knew I wanted to cook,” DiMambro said. “From a very young age, [going to] the pizzeria was always something I looked forward to. The smell of the oven, the wood fire, everything.”


While Gemelle’s Neapolitan pizza has arguably become Nantucket’s best slice, DiMambro’s craft has also captivated offisland audiences. In 2021, DiMambro attended the International Pizza Expo & Conference in Las Vegas, Nevada. Planning to make the dough at the competition, DiMambro packed a suitcase with flour, Nantucket water, homemade Gemelle mozzarella, Calabrian olive oil, Parmigiano (the “king of cheeses”) and an assortment of tomatoes.


But when he got to Nevada, an unexpected hurdle cut DiMambro’s competition entry short. When he opened his luggage at his hotel in Vegas, he found his clothes were covered in flour. After looking closer, he realized that TSA officers had cut his vacuum-sealed bag of flour open, presumably to screen for illicit substances. “I had two kilograms of flour in a big vacuum-sealed bag,” he said. “Obviously that didn’t look good on the X-ray.” Without his ingredients, he was forced to withdraw from the pizza-making portion of the games.


DiMambro returned to Vegas for the 2025 expo—this time with his dough prepared before the flight. Competing in the Neapolitan pizza division’s preliminary round, he rose past a hundred competitors and became one of five pizzaiolos to qualify for the finals. He finished in fourth place. “It really comes down to the quality of the ingredients. I think that’s what makes the difference,” DiMambro said. “It was crazy, you know, to place that high. I still can’t believe it.”


This winter, DiMambro hopes to return to the international competition stage. With a couple of modifications to the dough’s proofing time and the tomato sauce’s seasoning, he might rise to the top of the pizza world.

NEAPOLITAN MARGHERITA PIZZA


INGREDIENTS

  • 10 ounces pizza dough (available at Pizzeria Gemelle)
  • 2 ounces tomato sauce (available at Pizzeria Gemelle)
  • 2 ounces mozzarella
  • 4 to 6 basil leaves
  • Handful of pecorino Romano or Parmigiano
  • Drizzle of fresh olive oil
  • Dash of semolina (or cornmeal)


INSTRUCTIONS

  1. Preheat the oven to 550 degrees Fahrenheit, or as high as it can go. If you have a pizza stone, place the stone into the oven 45 minutes before you plan to bake.
  2. Take the dough—whatever your favorite recipe is—out of the fridge and let it temper for at least one hour. If the dough is colder than room temperature, it won’t be easy to sculpt, won’t rise correctly and will end up too chewy. On a cutting board or cookie sheet, stretch the dough evenly to a 12-inch diameter.
  3. Ladle the tomato sauce into the center of the dough and, using the bottom of the ladle, spread it out in a circular clockwise motion. Spread the sauce evenly, leaving 1 to 1.5 inches for the crust.
  4. Before adding the mozzarella to the pizza, cut the mozzarella balls into smaller pieces. If the mozzarella was stored in water, let it drain to reduce excess moisture. Distribute the mozzarella evenly across the pizza.
  5. Break up the basil into halves and lay them across the pizza. Drizzle olive oil across the pizza to your liking. Scatter a handful of pecorino Romano or Parmigiano over the pizza.
  6. If you have a pizza stone, lightly dust a cookie sheet with semolina to transfer your pizza onto the stone. If you don’t have a pizza stone, bake the pizza directly on a cookie sheet. At 550 degrees, bake the pizza for 5–7 minutes or until the crust is golden brown. If you prefer meltier cheese, finish it off on broil for up to 1 minute. Enjoy your pizza with another drizzle of olive oil and a sprinkle of Parmigiano.

Latest Stories


By N Magazine • November 19, 2026
Lisa & Tom's Nantucket wedding.
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Fashion
Nantucket Cottage Hospital’s longest employee retires
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Nantucket Cottage Hospital’s longest employee retires
Kezia Duarte on track to finish the six major marathons
By John Stanton • November 19, 2026
Kezia Duarte on track to finish the six major marathons
Barnaby's Cares provides hope.
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Barnaby's Cares provides hope.
Dan Pronk's lobster pot tree
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Dan Pronk's lobster pot tree
MORE STORIES