Tugging on Emotions


November 19, 2026

A Nostalgic Cruise on a Wooden Classic

Written by Brian Bushard

Photography by Kit Noble




Last year, Matthew and Erika Mercer were browsing the web for a new boat, the kind of search not too uncommon for lifelong boaters. When they saw a listing for a 45-year-old wooden Crosby tugboat, a bell went off. The only catch, the tugboat had been sitting unused for three years in someone’s boathouse on a small lake in rural Indiana, and it wouldn’t start, even when a mechanic tried. Looking for a challenge, Matthew and Erika took the next flight they could find to Indiana—just as they were returning from their own wedding.


 “The craftsmanship there is just unbelievable,” Erika said. After a half-day endeavor to get the motor running, another day hauling the oversized hull out of the lake, and a 900-mile trip to Nantucket Sound, they had their boat, as well as a new charter company they purchased called the Nantucket Tug Company. “It ticked all the boxes,” Erika said. “I actually had a list that I wrote down of my perfect boat that I wanted for this company before I saw this one, and it literally has everything.”

The Chugalugatug (its original name) now operates as the smallest harbor cruise boat on Nantucket. “Most Crosby tug boats are just a commercial hull, kind of empty, like a launch that’s meant for seating tons of people,” Matthew said. “But there are a couple of these Crosby tugs that were built. Most are not for sale, and they’re all kind of old and beat up.”


That’s not the case with the new boat. Despite sitting around in a boathouse on a lake for three years, the previous owners kept it in pristine condition. Built in the early ’80s in Osterville, Massachusetts, the 26-foot Crosby River Tug was designed by the original boat owner specifically for Lake Wawasee, a four-square-mile lake in northern Indiana farm country. The boat had not been moved from the lake since then.


What caught Erika and Matthew’s eye was the attention to detail. On top of the hull is a wooden cabin, complete with a wooden helm, which the Mercers freshly varnished once they purchased the boat. An original wood stove keeps the interior cabin heated, with shag carpeting and upholstered banquettes for people to cruise comfortably. On top of that, the boat had only 400 hours on it when Matthew and Erika purchased it, despite being in operation for 45 years cruising around Lake Wawasee.


“That’s like 1,000 miles on a car,” Erika said. “We have already put, in two seasons, another 400 hours on it. What it ran in its first 45 years of its life, we’ve doubled that.” While it’s not a true sister ship, the Chugalugatug was made in the same Cape Cod boatyard as the Nantucket Tug Company’s former boat, Gertrude, which former Nantucket Tug Company owners Jonas Baker and Tim Feeney ran for one season before the Mercers bought the company. Unlike the Chugalugatug’s wooden house, Gertrude was made of fiberglass and did not have the original carpeting the Chugalugatug has. “All that bronze casting [on the Chugalugatug] is custom,” Matthew said. “For a guy in a pontoon lake in Indiana to build that is incredible.”


As a smaller boat, sailing around Nantucket in the Chugalugatug is an inherently intimate experience. Over the past two years, Matthew and Erika have hosted over a dozen engagements on board their lunch and sunset cruises. One night, they even held a small wedding. While other Nantucket-based charter yachts offer full food and drink service, the Mercers allow customers to bring their own food and drinks on board. And for people who are looking for a catered experience, Nantucket Tug Company works with PPX for prepared food service. “I want it to be open to the public,” Matthew said. “With [The Westmoor Club’s yacht] Belle, you have to be a member of The Westmoor Club, which is $750 a year to join. With Barton and Gray [Mariners Club], you have to be a member of Barton and Gray. We want something where people can have that same experience.”

Latest Stories


By N Magazine • November 19, 2026
Lisa & Tom's Nantucket wedding.
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Fashion
Nantucket Cottage Hospital’s longest employee retires
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Nantucket Cottage Hospital’s longest employee retires
Kezia Duarte on track to finish the six major marathons
By John Stanton • November 19, 2026
Kezia Duarte on track to finish the six major marathons
Barnaby's Cares provides hope.
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Barnaby's Cares provides hope.
Dan Pronk's lobster pot tree
By brianbushard • November 19, 2026
Dan Pronk's lobster pot tree
MORE STORIES