Need to Read: September 2025
Tim Ehrenberg of “Tim Talks Books” gives you his top picks for the fall reading season.



The Widow by John Grisham
Twice by Mitch Albom
Heart the Lover by Lily King
October is turning into one of my favorite months on Nantucket and the same can be said for the publishing world. It’s a month for some of the most anticipated reads you don’t want to miss and the perfect time to get lost in a good book. Lily King is an auto-buy author for me and she gives us the gift of Heart the Lover this year. Lily is a writer’s writer, and this is a strikingly intimate novel about the lasting impact of first love. Fans of Writers & Lovers are in for a real treat. The Widow by John Grisham is coming October 21 and it’s his first whodunnit. Small-town lawyer Simon Latch is accused of murder and it’s up to him to find the real killer to clear his name. All rise for the honorable John Grisham, master of the legal thriller and now legal mystery. And don’t miss Twice by Mitch Albom, available October 25. The heart of Albom’s new novel asks: “What if you got to do everything in your life again?” I loved this short and sweet story so much that, you guessed it, I read it twice.

The Academy by Elin Hilderbrand and Shelby Cunningham
Let’s get back to school this month with my podcast co-host, friend and Queen of Nantucket beach reads, Elin Hilderbrand, who is back on shelves with
The Academy, a novel co-written with her daughter, Shelby Cunningham. Welcome to Tiffin Academy, a New England boarding school with just as much juicy drama, memorable characters and dreamy details as any of Hilderbrand’s Nantucket novels. Everything you love about her books is packed into these pages. Campus novels are some of my favorites: The Secret History, Prep, I Am Charlotte Simmons, Skippy Dies, The Art of Fielding, I Have Some Questions for You. Hilderbrand and Cunningham move to “head of the class” in the genre with this new novel, and have built a whole world to get lost in from various perspectives, from the students to the teachers, the parents and the school’s chef. By page six, you’ll feel so attached to the Tiffin “Thoroughbreds,” it’s as if you’re reading about your own alma mater. Cliffhangers abound by the last page, but have no fear—a sequel is in the works. Available September 16.
Order an autographed copy with exclusive gift and bookmark from nantucketbookpartners.com. Listen to Elin, Shelby and I discuss the writing of the novel on our podcast Books, Beach & Beyond.


Seduction Theory by Emily Adrian
What Happened to Lucy Vale by Lauren Oliver
If you loved
The Academy
and you are looking for more campus novels for the back-to-school season this month, check out
Seduction Theory and
What Happened to Lucy Vale.
Seduction Theory
introduces two married professors who tiptoe around infidelity. It’s dark academia at its finest with enough campus satire, classroom intrigue and great writing to keep you turning the pages.
What Happened to Lucy Vale
is addictively fun. Lucy, the new girl in school, moves into the Faraday House, where 16 years ago, Nina Faraday vanished without a trace. Now, Lucy is nowhere to be found, setting in motion another mystery to be investigated and solved two decades later. These dual timelines, multiple suspicions and secrets—along with generations of mystery and small-town gossip—make for the perfect autumn page-turner. You’ll never guess what happened to Lucy Vale

Buckeye by Patrick Ryan
Buckeye just might turn out to be my favorite book of the year. If you don’t trust me, my two favorite literary Ann’s (Ann Patchett and Ann Napolitano) loved it, too. It’s my favorite type of novel—a multi-generational epic from World War II to the late 20th century. Think of the very best of John Irving. We meet Cal Jenkins on the very first page: “Born in the spring of 1920 with one leg shorter than the other.” From this introduction come dozens of loveable characters who struggle against the backdrop of some of our most transformative decades in history. I read this 500-page saga in almost one sitting because I needed to know how everything turned out for all the residents of Bonhomie, Ohio. One or two times a year a book touches my heart in such a special way, almost unexplainable, and Buckeye did that in such a way that I’m almost at a loss for words. I hope it does the same for you. Look out for Patrick Ryan at the 2026 Nantucket Book Festival. Available September 2.

The Wilderness by Angela Flournoy
Some books you read and love for the characters, some for the fast-paced plot, and others for the setting. I recommend The Wilderness for the voice. Written in a memorable third-person, this is an era-defining novel about five Black women over the course of their 20-year friendship. There is something about a decades-long friend, someone who knows you better than you know yourself. That complexity of relationships is explored in these pages, and their friendship becomes a sixth character all on its own. The five friends must figure out what they mean to one another as they find their way through the wilderness, that period of life we all face when becoming an adult sinks in. Available September 16.
At the end of this month, I will co-host the first ever Aspen Literary Festival along with The New York Times Book Review editor Gilbert Cruz and broadcast journalist Alisyn Camerota from September 26-28, where I will interview Angela Flournoy, as well as authors Kevin Kwan, Jess Walter, Nathan Hill, Jane Hamilton, Adriana Trigiani and many more.

The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny by Kiran Desai
Long-listed for the Booker Prize, and from the same author who won the Booker for
The Inheritance of Loss
in 2006, The Loneliness of Sonia and Sunny
is that book. The 700-page tome that will sit on your shelf beckoning you, making you ask the question, “Do I want to commit the time?” The answer is a resounding yes. It’s a colder season novel in that you want to have a cup of coffee and a blanket to curl up with to sink into the story for hours and hours. We meet Sonia and Sunny and follow their love story, as well as the interconnected stories of their two families. It might sound like a simple premise, one that has been done many times before, but this is more a novel of ideas, an epic of love and family, India and America, tradition and modernity .It’s a true reader’s novel, one that will have you daydreaming of the characters and the plot and reflecting on your own human connections, the life you are living, and the people you are loving. Available September 2.

What We Can Know by Ian McEwan
What I know is this: Ian McEwan, the celebrated author of Atonement, has delivered yet another masterpiece. As a history aficionado, I am fascinated by digging into the past and weaving together threads to understand those who lived before us. This book, however, begins in the year 2119, as much of the Western World is underwater after a nuclear catastrophe. A lonely scholar is fascinated by the years 1990-2030, specifically a dinner party in 2014 where a famous poet reads a new composition aloud for his wife’s birthday to a group of friends. The poem goes missing and for a century, people will speculate about what exactly happened to the lost piece and the people who heard it read aloud. By using social media posts, emails, journals and digital information from the ’90s through the 2030s, the scholar hunts down and pieces together the words left behind to tell the full story. This is a literary mystery of the first order, one that is looking at the modern age from the future. We see how people living a century later will view our tastes, beliefs and stories. It also vividly explores the idea of what can ever be truly known across time and history. Available September 2.

The Elements by John Boyne
The first book I ever recommended in this magazine nine years ago was The Heart’s Invisible Furies by John Boyne, still one of my favorite novels of all time. Boyne is back with The Elements, a masterful quartet of four interconnected short stories: Water, Earth, Fire and Air. I was blown away by this gripping exploration of guilt, trauma and the human capacity for redemption. Each story represents a different perspective on crime: the enabler, the accomplice, the perpetrator and the victim. How each story is connected to the next and when and where characters from one of the narratives appear and intersect in the others was so expertly crafted. Trigger warnings of sexual assault are important to mention, but this book challenges readers to look at guilt and innocence on every page, what you would do when faced with the unimaginable, and how stories and characters, even the worst of humanity, can get under your skin and stay with you. Available September 9.