COLLISION COURSE?


November 18, 2022

New data points to an overpopulation problem on Nantucket in the near future.

story by Greta Feeney

photography by Kit Noble

For over a decade, Nantucket has been the fastest-growing county in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. For some, rapid population growth signals progress, promising a stronger post-COVID economic recovery. Others point to the island’s finite natural and human resources, continuously strained by a red-hot real-estate market that exacerbates the worsening housing crisis and a comorbid dearth of skilled workers to meet the growing needs of year-round and seasonal residents.


An airport without enough jet fuel, inadequate sanitation infrastructure at billion-dollar beaches, and too few firefighters to protect the major assets of the wealthy? While end-of-days geopolitical rhetoric might seem out of step with day-to-day life on this tiny piece of paradise thirty miles out to sea, there are real concerns for island residents when it comes to unfettered population growth.

In July, the Nantucket Community Data Platform released its latest population analysis. The numbers are still being mulled over by local officials, as the island absorbs the aftershocks of a busy summer season that included a rash of freakish car accidents, multiple petty crimes, and two massive fires. The fires were fought heroically by an understaffed fire department, whose efforts—but for providence and a spell of timely rain—could easily have been overwhelmed by blazes swift and powerful enough to subsume large swaths of the island.


Much in line with what we have all been feeling, CDP’s new Nantucket data set points toward a trend of continuous, exponential growth—confirming a 73.6 percent increase in the peak population since 2014, which, unchecked, will nearly double again in eight years. While a trend-line isn’t necessarily predictive—it doesn’t mean the peak population will reach 100,000 people by 2030—based on CDP’s air-tight, peer-reviewed process, it certainly looks that way.

Town officials, already tasked with resilience planning and mitigation efforts aimed at protecting Nantucket's infrastructure and coastal ecosystems from the inevitable impact of climate change, must now also consider the implications of population surges of this magnitude. With the gridlocked clash of interests in the housing market still very much at play, how can Nantucket plan ahead and avoid becoming a proverbial canary in a coal mine to other coastal communities facing a similar confluence of challenges?


Alan Worden, founder and CEO of CDP, considers the results of the study. “Some of the insights show a trend which is provocative, around which leaders can say, ‘If this growth continued to be a reality, what does it mean for the systems on the island? What does it mean for drinking water, waste, public transportation, schools, tourism, traffic?’ And so we do this not as an academic exercise—we do it as a very practical exercise where leaders can engage with reliable, high-confidence data and ideally do their jobs better.”

As restaurants face the challenge of finding adequate staff housing, an increase in visitors in need of dining options points to a growing demand for pre-packaged foods, which will in turn negatively impact the island’s waste stream and landfill capacity. An increase in peak-season traffic can present logistical impediments to effective law enforcement, especially first responders like firefighters, who are already too few in number and are facing the additional infrastructural challenge of inadequate fire hydrants to protect homes in more remote neighborhoods.

Matt Fee, owner of Something Natural, opines on CDP’s latest findings: “These figures also confirm the difficulty we all are having attracting and retaining staff. More visitors and fewer employees isn’t sustainable.” Fee cites traffic and degraded water quality as ongoing concerns listed in the town’s Comprehensive Community Plan. “Hopefully CDP’s population data, confirming what we are all feeling, will help build the political will to have the tough conversations about what is necessary to retain or enhance the quality of life for all residents.”


But what is the actual tipping point, and is there such a thing as a real constraint? “It’s not the ferries,” says Worden, “and it's not the airlines, either. In fact, flight service to and from Nantucket is set to expand.” Without restrictions on travel to and from the island, the data speaks directly to pressures and constraints felt by the year-round and seasonal labor forces—an 18 percent increase in year-round workers has been offset by a 13 percent reduction in temporary workers. This means that the average peak-season worker is now serving more than twice the number of individuals they did in 2014, a problem seriously exacerbated by the housing shortage. According to Worden, “An overcrowded classroom analogy is not inappropriate here.”


But for many year-round and long-time residents, overcrowding is not just an analogy—it’s a reality ironized by the island’s accommodations toward certain demographics, whose empty homes and corporate de facto hotels serve as echo chambers to the continuous call for affordable housing. Affordable housing is key to attracting and retaining a vibrant middle-class community of skilled and essential workers, without which a universal erosion of the quality of life on Nantucket is inevitable.


While continuous growth in the tourism sector means more consumer spending to fuel the economy, it also invariably brings along a host of undesirables: crowded streets, noise, pollution, car accidents, and crime. A workforce that includes adequate police, firefighters, teachers, and public and healthcare workers is critical to prevent Nantucket’s slide into a dystopic, gated community—a Dickensian juxtaposition of the very rich and the very poor, where we find ourselves looking backward rather than to the future.

Latest Stories


By brianbushard August 3, 2026
Written by Brian Bushard Photography by Kit Noble While they may not be household names in the true Hollywood sense, Nantucket’s summer population includes powerful producers, screenwriters and editors who are behind the scenes on the movies we all recognize. Indeed, Nantucket has an underground entertainment community that is in effect a hidden Hollywood.“I got involved in the Nantucket Film Festival before we bought a house on the island,” said Marc Resteghini, a producer with Amazon MGM Studios who executive produced the series Young Sherlock. “As I started to learn a little bit more about the festival itself, I started to realize there were a lot of people who either lived on the island or vacationed here from the entertainment industry.” Resteghini was named the new chair of the film festival this June. While Nantucket has a reputation for attracting politicians and Wall Street titans, lesser known is the fact that dozens of leaders in the entertainment industry have also found Nantucket as their summer refuge, just not the names you might know. “It’s like Sergeant Pepper Lonely Heart Club Band,” actor John Shea said. “We see each other but the last thing we want to do is talk about the film business. It’s more of a quiet acknowledgement of a fellow traveler thana fellowship.” “The Vineyard is where all the actors and the writers go, the creatives,” documentary film producer Annabelle Dunne added. Dunne summers on Nantucket. “I think a lot of people that work in Hollywood come here to be with their families, relax and enjoy Nantucket, not to network. But it is a small island, and sometimes when you take away the work component and you say we’re just getting together to get together, then things can happen.” 
By Jack Bradner August 3, 2026
Written by Jack Bradner Photography by Kit Noble 
By brianbushard August 3, 2026
Written by Brian Bushard Photography by Kit Noble There are family vacations and there are family vacations. Some people take their kids to Disney World, some take their kids to a Caribbean resort. But Dan and Sarah Gault have taken family travel to an entirely different level. This August, the Gault family will take an 11-month trip of a lifetime from their house on Nantucket to 18 countries on three continents, traveling like vagabonds through Africa, Asia and Australia. Their four school-aged kids will join them for the entire length of the vacation, ditching the comforts of life on Nantucket for an education they would never receive in school. “On this trip, forget about watching a big screen TV,” Dan said. “We’re talking about things like clean drinking water and having electricity 24 hours a day. Showing them those things gives them perspective. It plants a seed in them for a lifetime.” The Gaults, by their own admission, are not ordinary travelers. Since their trip will take nearly a year, their four children—in eighth, seventh, fifth and third grade—will be homeschooled through a math and English curriculum, as well as a healthy dose of reading, journaling and cultural visits to museums and historical sites. Instead of a beach resort vacation, they’ll be in city centers and remote parks, immersing themselves in new cultures and languages. And since the children are growing—and taking up more space in their house on the island—the entire trip will coincide with a yearlong project to lift their house in Warren’s Landing, making more space for the family of six to spread out. For the time they’re gone, Sarah, a special education teacher at Nantucket Public Schools, will be on sabbatical and set to return for the 2027-2028 school year. Dan, who owns a property management company, handed the reins to his second-in-command for the time being. “My whole team stepped up to make this possible,” he said. “I was anxious to tell two groups of people—my employees, because I didn’t want them jumping ship, and my clients in the management world, because I didn’t want them to be upset. But they were maybe the most supportive.”
By Jen Laskey August 1, 2026
Four Drinks for August Written by Jen Laskey August inspires us to squeeze every last drop out of summer. Whether you’re ticking experiences off your end-of-season bucket list or practicing the lost art of doing nothing, or a little of both, Nantucket’s drink experts have the perfect pours to help you make the most of summer’s last call—from a Cointreau-based spritz to a Portuguese white blend and a lush bourbon and beach plum cocktail. Let’s all linger in summertime a little longer. COINTREAU CITRUS SPRITZ ($19.99, 750 ML bottled cocktail at The Islander) COINTREAU L’UNIQUE ORANGE LIQUEUR ($48.99, 750 ML bottle at The Islander) Recommended by ZEINA METRI,co-owner, The Islander If August has you in the mood for ready-to-serve simplicity, Zeina Metri recommends the Cointreau Citrus Spritz. It’s made with French white wine and natural citrus flavors, and the star ingredient is Cointreau, anorange liqueur distilled in western France that’s often used in margaritas and cosmopolitans. “Cointreau is such a versatile liqueur,” noted Metri. “It’s crafted from a blend of sweet and bitter orange peels and gives cocktails a depth and balance that elevates every other ingredient around it.”The Cointreau Citrus Spritz comes in two flavors—Orange & Blood Orange and Lemon & Lime. It’s light enough to day-drink with friends on a warm afternoon or to sip while watching those last summer sunsets. With its low alcohol level (10.5% ABV) and resealable screw cap, it’s perfect for a month when all you want to do is chill. Just pour it over ice and voila! “The Cointreau Spritz is bright, refreshing and vibrant without being overly sweet,” said Metri. And if you’d rather make your own, simply pour a splash of Cointreau into something bubbly. LUÍS SEABRA, GRANITO CRU DÃO BRANCO, BLEND OF ENCRUZADO, BICAL AND CERCIAL, 2022 ($155/bottle at Galley Beach Restaurant) Recommended by IEVA ALDINS, Wine Director, Galley Beach Restaurant Every summer has that one unforgettable discovery, and this year it might just be Luís Seabra’s Granito Cru Dão Branco, a white blend of three native Portuguese grapes: encruzado, bical and cerceal. “This wine is sunshine in a glass,” said Ieva Aldins, wine director of Galley Beach Restaurant. “It [has] mouth-watering acidity, voluptuous elegance, minerality and salinity that make it a perfect summer sipper.” Seabra is one of Portugal’s top winemakers. “He used to make wines for Niepoort Winery but now focuses on his own old-vine and terroir-driven wines,” said Aldins. “His Cru series focuses on sourcing vineyard sites with high mineral content—as the name [Granito] suggests.” Aldins recommends sipping the Granito Cru by the beach and pairing it with shellfish and seafood. “I particularly love it with our crab cake or lobster spring roll, as it has both the body to hold up to these dishes and the acidity to hold up to their richness,” she said. BEACH PLUM RUSH($16 at The Fairgrounds) Recommended by CONRAD MEURICE Bar Manager, The Fairgrounds The blushy golden-orange color and tart, floral notes from beachplum honey give this cocktail an unmistakably late-summer vibe. The Beach Plum Rush is one of the most popular signature drinks at the new Fairgrounds restaurant, said bar manager Conrad Meurice. “It brings together a traditional Kentucky straight bourbon with some local flavor flair of beach plum,” he said. “We balance out the cocktail with some fresh lemon juice and add Angostura bitters for a crisp citrusy finish with a hint of spice.”A riff on the Gold Rush, a type of whiskey sour made with honey rather than simple syrup, Meurice’s Beach Plum Rush gets an additional pop of flavor from honey that he infuses with beach plum. You can buy beach plum honey at local specialty food shops, but Meurice says you can also quickly mix up your own by stirring a little beach plum jam into some local honey. Best sipped at The Fairgrounds’ new flower bar, the Beach Plum Rush is a great pairing partner for the restaurant’s beet salad with salmon or shrimp, or the tuna poke bowl. Makes 1 serving - Glassware: Rocks glass Ingredients: - 2 ounces Kentucky straight bourbon• ¾ ounce lemon juice • ¾ ounce beach plum honey• Dash of Angostura bitters Instructions:
By brianbushard July 31, 2026
Written by Brian Bushard Photography by Kit Noble A taste of New York has arrived on Nantucket. By 10 a.m. on a Saturday, the bagels at Slow to Rise Bakery’s stand at the farmer’s market have all but sold out. Down the street, Bagel Bar (opened in June by the owners of sushi restaurant Bar Yoshi, no less), is peddling freshly baked bagels. Meanwhile, Nantucket coffee conglomerate Roastd is baking bagels at its Airport Gas shop for its four island locations. And on Old South Road, the Meat & Fish Market is baking bagels every single morning. “It seems there has been a bagel explosion,” Bagel Bar owner Marc Knight said over a brunch of bagel sandwiches and Italian paninis. “This whole idea started a year ago and [Bagel Bar] opened briefly last year. But when we hatched the idea, there wasn’t as much of a bagel scene.” But over the past few years, Nantucket’s breakfast scene has started to look a lot more like something out of Brooklyn. At the Meat & Fish Market, owner Sean Ready has been baking bagels in house and serving heaping bagel sandwiches since he opened the shop nine years ago. The Meat & Fish Market even introduced a Cisco bagel, made with the brewery’s Whale’s Tale Pale Ale. Meanwhile, the duo of Tucker Puljic and Katrina Newfrock have been running Slow to Rise on Nantucket since 2022, with classics like plain, poppy seed and cinnamon sugar, to a Middle Eastern za’atar spice bagel, an English muffin bagel and an Italian-style cacio e pepe bagel with Parmigiano-Reggiano and black peppercorns. This isn’t the first time Nantucket has seen everything bagels everywhere. In the mid-1990s, Nantucket got its first taste of New York bagels, when Big Apple transplant Brad Moore opened Bagel Basin behind the former restaurant 21 Federal. Not one month later, there was a second bagel shop, The Nantucket Bagel Company, which was later purchased by Something Natural. The Gaslight even baked its own bagels for a time for Sunday brunches, serving smoked salmon or bluefish on bagels and tuna tataki or Italian cold-cuts in bagel sandwiches—with mimosas and Bloody Marys. Where Nantucket’s burgeoning bagel scene goes from here is to be seen. But if one thing is true, this is no half-baked idea. “The popularity of bagels has exploded in the last 10 years,” said Chris Dadey, a food and beverage consultant for Roastd. “It’s a little bit of New York culture moving north."
By brianbushard July 31, 2026
A Taste Of Jamaica At the Chicken Box Written by Brian Bushard Photography by Kit Noble Recipe By Peticea Murray The Chicken Box as a venue is known for its music and bar scene, but during the day thereis a completely different vibe. In June, Peticea Murray started bringing her food truck, 876 Island Cuisine, to the Box. By the time the lunch crowd arrives, the truck, which takes its name from Jamaica’s area code, is slammed with customers.“A lot of the island workforce is built by Jamaicans,” said Murray, who grew up cooking with her grandmother in Montego Bay. “I have a passion for it, but I myself did not have anywhere to buy this authentic Jamaican food [on Nantucket]. I thought I have to have a Jamaican restaurant so my people can have somewhere to have authentic Jamaican food, and not only that, to bring Jamaican culture through food to the Nantucket native people.”Murray’s truck offers staples like jerk chicken, as well as escovitch fish, rice and peas (red kidney beans are typically used, but the name comes from the local red peas in Jamaica), and coconut water straight out of the coconut. “[My grandmother] taught me all the old recipes, all the good stuff,” she said. “That’s why I cook the way I cook, because it’s coming from generations of authentic flavors.” JAMAICAN RICE AND PEAS, yields 8-10 servings Ingredients: -2 cups long-grain rice, washed -2 cups cooked red kidney beans (or 1 can, drained and rinsed) -1 can (13.5 ounces) coconut milk -2 cups water(reserved from cooking beans) -3 cloves garlic, minced -4 sprigs fresh thyme -2 scallions, chopped -1 small onion, chopped -1 whole Scotch bonnet pepper(do not cut it open) -1 teaspoon salt (or to taste) -½ teaspoon black pepper -1 tablespoon butter Instructions: In a large pot, combine the kidney beans, coconut milk, bean liquid (or water),onion, garlic, thyme, scallions, salt, black pepper and butter. Add the whole Scotch bonnet pepper and bring everything to a gentle boil. Let it simmer for about 10 minutes so the flavors develop. Cover the pot with a tight-fitting lid, reduce the heat to low and cook for 20-25 minutes, or until the rice is tender and all the liquid has been absorbed. Remove the Scotch bonnet pepper and thyme stems. Fluff the rice and gently with a fork before serving. CHEF’S TIP: The key to authentic Jamaican rice and peas is allowing the coconut milk, thyme, scallions, garlic and the Scotch bonnet pepper to simmer together before adding the rice. This creates the rich, flavorful base that makes the dish stand out. Keeping the Scotch bonnet whole adds its signature aroma without making the rice overly spicy. This recipe pairs perfectly with jerk chicken, curry goat, brown stew chicken, oxtail or escovitch fish.
MORE STORIES